When was 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ last sold?

44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ last sold in 2016 for $355,000.

What is the assessed value of 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ?

44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ is assessed at $518,300 (land plus improvements).

What is 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ worth?

Our model estimates 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ at $650,098, based on comparable recorded sales nearby.

How many units does 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ have?

44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ has 1 dwelling unit on record.

ElasticParcelNJ

Loading…

Save searches, owner alerts, and pro features

44 Carey Avenue

Butler, NJ·Morris County

Estimated market value

$650,098

high confidence

range $608,281 – $678,777

Assessment-implied: $595,747; Equalization ratio 0.8700 (2025)
Comp-implied: $668,215; 13 comparable sales

Based on 13 comparable sales

Last sale

$355,000

5/17/2016

Owner contactPro · unlock

Owner email, phone, and authorized agent are available on Pro.

Property

Type

Residential 1-4 unit

Tax class

Residential 1-4 unit

Year built

1990

Building size

2,268 sq ft

Lot size

0.14 ac

Land description

50X122

Building description

2S-AL-2-1U

Dwelling / commercial units

1 dw / 0 comm

Tax & Assessment

Net assessed value

$518,300

Land value

$234,300

Improvement value

$284,000

Last year's tax

$11,981

Sale on tax record

$355,000

Deed date

5/2/2016

Owner mailing addressPro · unlock

Owner name and mailing address are available on Pro.

Sales history

5/2/2016$355,000
Bk 22908 / Pg 581
11/18/2003$1
Bk 6011 / Pg 5
10/25/1993$190,000
Bk 3871 / Pg 329

Date	Price	Book / Page
5/2/2016	$355,000	22908 / 581
11/18/2003	$1	6011 / 5
10/25/1993	$190,000	3871 / 329

Deeds

No recorded deeds yet. Click Get deed list to pull the title chain from the county clerk.

Properties on Carey Avenue

Properties on Block 12

Frequently asked

When was 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ last sold?: 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ last sold in 2016 for $355,000.
What is the assessed value of 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ?: 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ is assessed at $518,300 (land plus improvements).
What is 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ worth?: Our model estimates 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ at $650,098, based on comparable recorded sales nearby.
How many units does 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ have?: 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ has 1 dwelling unit on record.
What kind of property is 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ?: It is a Residential Property.

Parcel ID1403·block 12·lot 23.01

Loading parcel record…

44 Carey Ave

44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ — owner, sales, deeds · ElasticParcel

44 Carey Avenue

Butler, NJ·Morris County

Estimated market value

$650,098

high confidence

range $608,281 – $678,777

Assessment-implied: $595,747; Equalization ratio 0.8700 (2025)
Comp-implied: $668,215; 13 comparable sales

Based on 13 comparable sales

Last sale

$355,000

5/17/2016

Owner contactPro · unlock

Owner email, phone, and authorized agent are available on Pro.

Property

Type

Residential 1-4 unit

Tax class

Residential 1-4 unit

Year built

1990

Building size

2,268 sq ft

Lot size

0.14 ac

Land description

50X122

Building description

2S-AL-2-1U

Dwelling / commercial units

1 dw / 0 comm

Tax & Assessment

Net assessed value

$518,300

Land value

$234,300

Improvement value

$284,000

Last year's tax

$11,981

Sale on tax record

$355,000

Deed date

5/2/2016

Owner mailing addressPro · unlock

Owner name and mailing address are available on Pro.

Sales history

5/2/2016$355,000
Bk 22908 / Pg 581
11/18/2003$1
Bk 6011 / Pg 5
10/25/1993$190,000
Bk 3871 / Pg 329

Date	Price	Book / Page
5/2/2016	$355,000	22908 / 581
11/18/2003	$1	6011 / 5
10/25/1993	$190,000	3871 / 329

Deeds

No recorded deeds yet. Click Get deed list to pull the title chain from the county clerk.

Properties on Carey Avenue

Properties on Block 12

Frequently asked

When was 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ last sold?: 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ last sold in 2016 for $355,000.
What is the assessed value of 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ?: 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ is assessed at $518,300 (land plus improvements).
What is 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ worth?: Our model estimates 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ at $650,098, based on comparable recorded sales nearby.
How many units does 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ have?: 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ has 1 dwelling unit on record.
What kind of property is 44 Carey Avenue, Butler, NJ?: It is a Residential Property.

Parcel ID1403·block 12·lot 23.01

Address	Sold	Price
239 Terrace Lake Dr	4/21/2026	$580,000
265 Winthrop Dr	12/30/2025	$454,500
21 Spring St	12/29/2025	$850,000
474 Cambridge Dr	12/3/2025	$417,500
378 Cambridge Dr	10/7/2025	$414,900
218 Terrace Lake Dr	5/23/2025	$545,000
218 Terrace Lake Dr	2/10/2025	$387,000
18 Cascade Way	1/31/2025	$550,000
490 Cambridge Dr	10/1/2024	$430,000
314 Cambridge Dr	8/7/2024	$406,250
18 Cascade Way	7/9/2024	$557,500
234 Terrace Lake Dr	12/7/2023	$450,000
7 Second St	7/18/2023	$590,000

Estimated market value

Owner contact🔒Pro · unlock

Property

Tax & Assessment

Sales history

Deeds

Frequently asked

Estimated market value

Owner contact🔒Pro · unlock

Property

Tax & Assessment

Sales history

Deeds

Frequently asked

Owner contactPro · unlock

Owner contactPro · unlock